Beyond ‘digital detox’: The complex work of navigating technologies in schools

Source: StockSnap on pixabay

Over recent months, some of my work as a school principal has involved navigating the opportunities, risks and responsibilities associated with technologies in schools, from staff use of artificial intelligence to the security of information held in digital systems and the public sharing of students’ images. Across these areas, I have been considering how schools might harness the possibilities of technologies while protecting the safety, dignity and agency of young people, in a landscape where capabilities and risks are evolving faster than research, regulation and institutional practice can keep pace.

Earlier this month, Australian education ministers announced a ‘digital detox’ for Australian schools, agreeing to introduce, trial or consider limits on screen use and restrictions on some uses of generative artificial intelligence. The announcement followed the release of the Australian Government’s A Digital Detox paper (Department of Education, 2026), which draws together research and policy developments relating to digital technologies, learning and student wellbeing.

The phrase ‘digital detox’ is memorable and accessible, communicating a clear message to the public. It reflects legitimate concerns about children’s attention, learning and wellbeing, including excessive screen exposure, digital distraction and the displacement of valuable learning experiences. Limits and restrictions have their place, as do opportunities for learning through pen and paper, conversation, play and hands-on experience. Yet a detox implies a toxin, something to be eliminated and then abstained from. The language can evoke a binary understanding of technology: on or off, present or absent. Educational decisions require us to look beyond simplistic frames, and to consider what technologies are being used, by whom, for what purposes, in which contexts, and with what benefits, risks and consequences.

The government’s paper acknowledges some of this complexity, recognising that different forms of screen use are associated with different outcomes, and that educational technologies should be purposeful, evidence-informed and supportive of learning. The work of schools is to navigate nuance as they interpret and enact these principles within their particular contexts. Across Australia, schools are moving in different directions, some tightening limits on devices, others actively exploring AI in teaching and learning. These approaches are not necessarily mutually exclusive.

At my school, we emphasise developmental appropriateness, teacher-directed technology use, screen-free opportunities, digital citizenship and the gradual development of student agency, within a relational, human-centred environment of learning and care. We are also thinking further about the responsibilities that sit beyond the visible use of devices in classrooms.

The less visible work of digital leadership

Much of the work of navigating technologies in schools happens away from classrooms. Families might notice a change in how a school seeks consent or shares images of students. They are less likely to see the policy drafts, risk registers and committee papers behind those changes, or the conversations among colleagues that shape them.

In developing our approach to staff use of artificial intelligence, for example, a restrictive approach may offer clarity but can limit experimentation and learning. Uncritical adoption brings its own risks, from the exposure of sensitive information to the gradual erosion of the thinking and expertise that professional practice requires. Framing AI use as an either-or decision risks overlooking more useful questions: what might it be used for, with what information, and with what consequences? What might be the consequences of not engaging?

Another area of deliberation is the sharing of student photographs and video. In July, the eSafety Commissioner warned that AI has changed the risks associated with publicly available images. Photographs can be copied, manipulated or sexualised, while names, uniforms, locations and routines can combine to identify students and create safety risks.

Schools also have good reasons to share images of young people learning, performing, creating and achieving. These stories recognise contributions and connect communities. As we consider the risks, I wonder how we might protect children without unnecessarily limiting their opportunities to be seen, heard and celebrated. How do we respect their developing capacity to make decisions about their digital identities?

The landscape also extends to systems and information beyond students’ direct use of devices. A school can make careful decisions about screen exposure while facing risks through third-party platforms, data retained by providers, technologies used by staff and material already circulating online. Some of these risks have little to do with how long a student spends looking at a screen.

Aon’s (2026) Independent Schools Risk Report ranked cyber risk first for the second consecutive survey. Strikingly, 29% of respondents were unsure whether their school had experienced an AI-related incident negatively affecting students, compared with 15% who reported one. This cannot tell us how many incidents went undetected, but it raises questions about our collective capacity to recognise and respond to emerging harms.

Critical thinking and agency

There is much thinking that happens between a broad policy direction and its enactment in a school. There are questions of educational purpose, research evidence, student needs, safety, agency and organisational responsibility. There are different perspectives to hear, competing considerations to weigh, and decisions to revisit as circumstances and our understanding change.

In September 2026, education ministers and designated representatives from around the world adopted a UNESCO statement on sustaining education as a common good in the age of AI. It calls for teachers to participate in decisions about the AI systems used in their classrooms, for AI to support rather than circumvent students’ thinking, and for age-appropriate safeguards, protection of children’s data, equity and public accountability.

These principles resonate with my experience. If we want students to be critical, discerning and ethical users of technology, teachers and school leaders need time and space to develop and exercise those same capabilities, asking difficult questions and bringing their professional knowledge of students and learning to decisions. For students, digital literacy extends beyond operating technologies to evaluating what they produce and recognising the interests embedded within them.

In an age of generative AI, students need opportunities to consider when a technology might support their understanding and when it might allow them to bypass the intellectual effort through which understanding develops, what I have previously described as the beauty of the cognitive detour. Such capacities develop through education, dialogue, modelling and experience, alongside schools’ responsibility for creating environments in which young people are protected while gradually developing independence and agency.

If we want young people to engage with technologies thoughtfully and safely, we need to attend not only to how much time they spend on screens, but also to the quality of the thinking, judgement and care that shape the decisions adults make about technology on their behalf, and increasingly with them.

References

Aon. (2026). Aon 2026 independent schools risk report. Aon Australia.

Australian Government Department of Education. (2026). A digital detox. https://www.education.gov.au/schooling/resources/digital-detox

eSafety Commissioner. (2026, July 28). Sharing school imagery in the age of AI: Risks, deepfakes, and how to protect students and staff. https://www.esafety.gov.au/newsroom/blogs/sharing-school-imagery-in-the-age-of-ai-risks-deepfakes-and-how-to-protect-students-and-staff

UNESCO. (2026, September 9). Education ministers call for education to remain a common good in the age of AI at UNESCO’s Digital Learning Week. https://www.unesco.org/en/articles/education-ministers-call-education-remain-common-good-age-ai-unescos-digital-learning-week?hub=370

Leave a Reply